13 Dec
Posted by Sam Jackson as Admissions, College, Harvard, Ivy League, Teenagers, Yale, stress
I know a lot of people have recently been coming to the site via CollegeConfidential or panicked “Yale 2012 how to survive after deferral” googling. It’s amazing for me to remember where I was last year this time (Exeter, NH) what I was doing (finals) and how I was feeling (more stressed than any other time in my entire life, ever). This past week I popped my head in at CC a little to try to tell people to 1. get off CollegeConfidential at least for the duration of the waiting time and 2. to try to instill some hope and raise some spirits (things which CC often takes away and dashes, I might add).
I saw the other day a post by a fellow yalie (name withheld by request) who wrote a post that I will reprint here, because I think it sends a very good message. I will definitely be writing one of my own as soon as I am done with this massive paper weighing over my head, but for now you’ll just have to hear from an anonymous fellow yalie. I don’t agree with every word, but it’s a pretty good message.
Hi! As a class of ‘11 yalie, i can tell you that lots of people on campus are excited that in a little over a day there will be several hundred new prospective yalies! As a former SCEA applicant, i can also understand how anxious many of you are right now. So before you log on to admits.yale.edu and get what you may think is the most critical result of your life up to this point, i wanted to share some thoughts.
Yale was my absolute first choice when i applied early action. I wanted to be in the northeast, the campus is beautiful, the residential college system really does work (ie, i don’t want to imagine what this semester would have been like if i didn’t have berkeley, but that’s beyond the point of this note), and as much as i hate to admit it, the huge endowment and name are big selling points. Yale also has its share of flaws, and if you have a romantic notion of a perfect life following your admission (as i did), you’ve been misled.
I don’t mean to tell you that you shouldn’t be excited about tomorrow. Yale is a great college and you’ve accomplished something very difficult if you’re accepted. What i do think you should know is that i’ve often thought i could have been just as satisfied, if not more satisfied, with a different college experience. Yale isn’t a perfect place, and yale isn’t “the one.” So if tomorrow at fiveish (for the most eager among you, i believe you could access the results at around 4:15 last year) you don’t see a big blue screen with a bulldog replacing the A in YALE, know that life is not over. Know that for most of us there really is no “one,” and that your college experience will be what you make of it. Know that my sister, who is every bit as smart as i am but went to a college that US News and World Report ranks below their top fifty liberal arts colleges, had a more satisfying college experience than i’ve had this semester. Know that Yale is a great place with interesting people and lots of options, but know that there are lots of great places with similar resources. Know that four years from now, you’re only going to have had one college experience and the quality of that experience is mostly dependent upon the attitude with which you approach it.
So for those of you who do see the bulldog tomorrow, know this: you are very lucky. Visit Yale, live our lives for a few days, and decide if this is the right place for you. The large majority of you will come to that conclusion, and that’s a testament to the magic of Yale. For those of you who don’t see that bulldog, it’s imperative that you embrace what i could not: If you had a realistic shot at Yale, you’re in very good shape and will be admitted to many other colleges, likely including several of Yale’s peer schools. What’s more (and more important), wherever you end up, your experience is contingent upon your outlook and actions more than anything else. There is no “one”, and the one you choose is just as likely as anywhere else to be the absolute best experience possible for you.
Best of luck, wherever tomorrow takes you.
~A bulldog ‘11
[Originally on CC here]
Good luck again to everyone waiting. Try to stay sane. I know that by 24 hours until results were out, I had literally started counting minutes, and that by 12 hours before decisions I was counting–I wish I was kidding–every second… try to avoid that, and try to relax, if that’s at all possible.
11 Responses
Rachel
December 13th, 2007 at 9:16 pm
1I’ll absolutely agree with this post. I followed your blog last year, while I was in the middle of my own college waiting game for Brown ED. I was deferred, and then rejected, and I’m at Brandeis now.
And every time I see people from high school and they ask about whether I wish I was at Brown, I tell them that I’m so thankful that they rejected me. Sure, I probably would have been happy at Brown, but I can’t imagine it being as perfect a fit as Brandeis has turned out to be.
Ivy League isn’t everything. Rankings aren’t everything. And just because you thought a place was perfect during the early application season doesn’t mean you’re necessarily right. Brandeis was pretty much a safety school, and I find myself challenged in classes every day. My friends are amazing, I’m more involved on campus than I ever was in high school, and the only thing I ever complain about is my roommate situation, which could be a problem anywhere you go.
Sam Jackson
December 13th, 2007 at 9:29 pm
2Great to hear that, Rachel! Just goes to show what the dirty little secret of college admissions is: people tend to be happy wherever they end up, once they’re there. Cognitive dissonance, a little bit, but a lot is just the normal common denominators of college life at so many college campuses and the adaptability of motivated students to novel environments!
Hope you’re having fun with the snow–I’m jealous of everyone back home in MA, as we here in New Haven do not nearly have enough (or good enough) snow for my tastes. *sigh* @ Connecticut weather, I guess. Too bland!
Rachel
December 14th, 2007 at 12:32 am
38 inches or so of fresh powder. The Ultimate teams decided it would be a good idea to go play in this weather, so I just got back from that, and then we ran into people who were sledding on dining hall trays. AMAZING.
Be jealous of our mighty MA weather!
Jen
December 14th, 2007 at 6:58 pm
4Deferred, unfortunately.
Would have been nice to be accepted.
I guess better this than an outright rejection.
Yale’s still the only Ivy I’d go to.
Haven’t applied to any other Ivy actually.
Unless you want to call Stanford an ivy.
Joe
December 15th, 2007 at 4:51 pm
5like you, Jen… I don’t think I want to go to another Ivy League besides Yale. I was deferred as well… I just wish I knew why. I’m first in my class, got a 2290 on my SATs, was a foreign exchange student my sophomore year, have a 4.5 average on my AP Tests, am a varsity runner, work 20 hours a week at Subway, and do just about everything my school offers (President of United Way Club and Treasurer of Key Club), and even started a new Model United Nations Club there. And I attend a small public school- I’m actually the first person to apply to Yale from there ever. I mean, I haven’t done any ground-breaking research or won any national championships, but I really though I had a pretty decent chance, considering my parents haven’t had the money to send me to an elite private school since the time I was in first grade… I just don’t understand what more I could possibly have done.
Jen
December 19th, 2007 at 9:04 pm
6I would love to know why, too.
I’ve never been deferred! (but I’ve never applied to college before either)
But I guess this is just more motivation for me to … find the cure for cancer or eradicate AIDS or get Paris Hilton to wear real clothes or something.
Don’t know if I can do any of this in three months, though - but I’m going to try!
…I wonder if Yale knows that I’m willing to give up the world’s most perfect weather for it.
Sam Jackson
December 25th, 2007 at 6:45 pm
7Don’t let college admissions consume your lives, guys–the dirty little secret of college admissions is that people end up happy wherever they go, generally speaking. Don’t let your love of Yale blind you to other great schools. As readers of my website, I’m sure you’re the cream of the crop ; ) and will have great options.
Jon
December 30th, 2007 at 9:52 pm
8I’ve been in despair for the past two weeks (I was deferred), so I’m glad that I came across this tonight (basically with a google search). I don’t know the reason either– 2320, top of my class, 800 on my SAT IIs, 5 on all of my APs, president of three clubs, national academic champion, musical theatre, taught myself Chinese, and I worked with a Yale genetic anthropology researcher over the summer (he wrote me a great recommendation). I guess that I’ll never know why, but I wish I had seen this earlier because it’s been tough putting together all of my other applications in such a disconcerted state
Jon
December 30th, 2007 at 9:53 pm
9I also know many others with similar credentials from my region (Westchester, NY) who were deferred too….
Jen
December 30th, 2007 at 10:23 pm
10I’m just crushing on Yale right now. Trust me, it isn’t full blown love (I hope it will be, but I know that I applied to some outstanding schools [no, not other Ivies... Yale was my only Ivy] and will most likely be just as happy there as at Yale).
Plus, I know far better students - more rounded, better at certain things - than myself who were also deferred and even rejected at Yale. I count myself lucky.
Congratulations Yale Class of 2012! | the Sam Jackson College Experience
March 31st, 2008 at 7:51 pm
11[...] [message originally posted in December] [...]
RSS feed for comments on this post · TrackBack URI
Leave a reply
Pages
Who is Sam Jackson?
Kind words about my blog:
Andrew Careaga calls it “a service to all of us in the higher ed marketing business.”
Christian Long says it has “dramatically inspired college admissions folks to take notice”
Bob Johnson says “I like [it] because I agree with so much of what he says.” and that “Paying attention what Sam writes will let you focus more closely on students who will actually attend your school.”
Karine Joly says my witty and fresh style “offers a rare glimpse at the mind of our elusive prospective students”
and TargetX calls my blog “good reading” and me “wise-beyond-my-years.”
Categories
Translate
Helpful Sponsors
Archives
Related
Recent Comments
Recent Posts
I coalesce the vapors of human existence into a viable and meaningful comprehension.
the Sam Jackson College Experience runs Wordpress and the BloggingPro theme by: Design Disease.
You're at the end of the page! Go back to the top or reload to read more.